Hotel Online
News for the Hospitality Executive

.
advertisement


TripAdvisor Caught Red-Handed

Glasgow's Bellgrove Hotel, a homeless shelter, finds itself in
TripAdvisor's Top 100 best hotels in the United Kingdom


by Georges Panayotis
April 30, 2013

The community site has again been caught in a flagrant act of deception basing a ranking for best British hotels on fanciful character appraisals.

Despite their «sophisticated algorithms» and their attentive «monitoring» of comments posted on the web, it has been duped by small pranksters who succeeded at getting a homeless shelter in the Top 100 of recommended establishments for the quality of its service in the United Kingdom.

If only it was the homeless who were sheltered for the night that judged on the comfort of the mattress, on the taste of the morning coffee, and the kindness of social workers…. not even! Anyone could have posted comments from their cell phones while returning on the metro or sidewalks. These are surely imposters who amused themselves by flooding the site with wacky praise. This could bring one to smile if the affair wasn’t an additional illustration of the lack of rigorous methodology and serious ethics to give a grade of sincere appreciation to a hotel. The ranking was quickly modified as the prank was easily discovered. But what proves that the rest of the ranking is more reliable? And what about the more classic hotels that are either victims of this conspiracy of defamation or lame ducks, raised in the rankings by agencies that specialize in good e-reputations?

TripAdvisor, and its consorts, show once again how an interesting idea was undermined by a lack of seriousness and by mixing genres. The absence of verifying actual stays before commenting on an establishment is the first unpardonable offense. It is otherwise surprising that the new Afnor standard, responsible for organizing the Farwest of commentary, has not marked this as an obligation. Any reliability is gravely called into question. More dangerous still is the potential use of TripAdvisor customer e-mail addresses. As with Facebook, its economic model relies on advertisement and the sale of information collected on the site’s visitors. Nothing excludes the hotel clients, regrouped and segmented, also used for commercial transactions for competing institutions.

By displaying a small plaque encouraging clients to give their comments on TripAdvisor, hoteliers do not realize that they are necessarily entering the Trojan horse in their PMS. When it has emptied their client data base, it will be time to complain about the bad economy and the invasion of OTAs. Guaranteed «pure beef», uncontrolled comments on community sites smell more and more like horse meat, a little spoiled. Should we wait for the autopsy of an industry to defend ourselves?

ABOUT MKG Group
Established in 1985 by Georges Panayotis, MKG Group has built a solid reputation for business expertise and substantial European-based know-how in the fields of tourism, lodging and food service. MKG Group meets the needs of each of its clients by providing valuable analytical and decision-making skills necessary for success. www.mkg-group.com

For further information , please contact :

MKG Group - International Development Department
Vanguelis Panayotis
T. : +33 (0)1 56 56 87 87
v.panayotis@mkg-group.com

MKG Hospitality - Media Contact
Michael Komodromou
Tel: +44 (0)20 7624 4030
press@mkg-group.com
Web: www.mkg-hospitality.com

 


Receive Your Hospitality Industry Headlines via Email for Free! Subscribe Here
 

To Learn More About Your News Being Published on Hotel-Online Inquire Here
.
Also See: Online Agency Practices, The Cup is Full; Join the Petition of Hoteliers Against OTA Practices / Georges Panayotis / October 2012

Accor Drops to 6th Place in the World Ranking Following the Sale of Motel 6 to Blackstone; Blackstone Becomes the Largest Hotel Owner in the World with Direct Control of 850,000 Rooms / May 2012

Top Ten Hotel Groups in Europe with Accor Continuing to Lead According to MKG Hospitality / February 2012

European Hospitality Results for 2011 Lie Somewhere Between Satisfaction and a Question Mark; European Union Averaged 5.5% RevPAR Growth / February 2012

2011 Was a Fine Year for French Hospitality: The Year-in-Review of the French Hotel Industry by MKG Group / January 2012

MENA Hotel Performances Bounce Back Posting Excellent RevPAR Growth / November 2011

U.S. Hotel Groups Still Dominate at Home with Hilton Leading the Pack; With Market Saturation Nearing, Groups Looking Abroad to Promote Products and Concepts / September 2011

Key Hotel Performance Indicators for the Middle East and North Africa Region (MENA) are Split Down the Middle / September 2011

Middle East & North Africa Hotel Markets End 2010 with Great Disparity, Uneasy Hotel Growth is Forecast / February 2011

Poland's Hotel Industry on Upward Trend with RevPAR and Occupany Steadily Growing / November 2010

The Top 10 Hotel Groups in the World; IHG Retains Top Spot With Nearly 650,000 Rooms / July 2010

The Top 10 Hotel Groups in the World; IHG Retains Top Spot Surpassing the 600,000 Room Mark / May 2009

Top Twenty Hotel Brands in the World at January 1, 2008, Also Top Ten Hotel Groups in the World / April 2008

The 2008 Top 20 European Hotel Brands Ranking and the Top Ten Hotel Groups Ranking / March 2008

Ranking - Top Ten Worldwide Hotel Chains Growth 1995-2005 / October 2005
. .

To search Hotel Online data base of News and Trends Go to Hotel.OnlineSearch

Home | Welcome| Hospitality News
| Industry Resources

Please contact Hotel.Online with your comments and suggestions.