Hotel Online
News for the Hospitality Executive





The Next Big Hotel Online Revenue Driver Is Here:
Google Hotel Price Ads (HPA)

by Sue Wiker and Sara O'Brien
April 23, 2013

There are a number of digital marketing initiatives that generate direct bookings, incremental revenues and high ROIs to the direct online channel such as SEO, SEM, email marketing and online media. Over the past few years several new revenue-generating digital marketing initiatives have emerged that, until recently, were only available to OTAs and major hotel brands. Requiring sophisticated CRS access, advertising middleware technology, and out-of-range minimum monthly spends, these initiatives have traditionally been inaccessible to independent properties, smaller and mid-size hotel and resort brands, and casinos.
 
One such revenue-generating opportunity is the Google Hotel Price Ads (HPA) program, comprised of sponsored price listings that appear throughout the Google universe: from Google Hotel Finder to Google+ Local (formerly Google Places), Google Maps, and the traditional search engine results pages (SERPs). These ads feature drop-down pricing menus that allow users to comparison shop by price; each listing features four vendors and their nightly rate.  Every click on an ad in the pricing menu results in a lead-generating fee paid by the advertiser in the form of CPC (cost-per-click), which varies based on how much the advertiser is willing to pay for the lead.

Google HPA works only if there is:
  • A real-time inventory availability and pricing feed structured specifically to Google HPA requirements
  • A dedicated advertising budget
  • Advertising middleware to:
    • Structure and translate the inventory availability and feed into "Google speak"
    • Manage daily and monthly budgets per property, campaigns and bids
    • Track conversions
    • Provide alerts and reporting
Google HPA is not a distribution channel, nor is it a “set and forget” initiative – it requires daily bid and ad spend management and optimization. It is part of a new digital advertising trend in the industry: convergence of hotel online distribution and hotel online marketing. This convergence requires hoteliers to have access to a sophisticated advertising middleware.
 
The HeBS Digital CPC Gateway is one such advertising middleware available to hoteliers today. Google’s availability and pricing feed is less than five percent of the complexity of this new “hybrid” advertising model. The most complex part is the advertising middleware needed to manage ad spend and budget on a daily and monthly and on a per property basis; real-time CPC bid management; campaign monitoring and ongoing optimizations; reporting and billing on property level.
 
In addition to Google HPA, this new CPC ad format is being used by Kayak.com, the new TripAdvisor Meta Search, Trivago, etc.
 
Google HPA was originally tested with and available only to OTAs, giving them an unfair advantage over the hotels. Later many major hotel brands joined the program, though, due to technology deficiencies and lack of sophisticated advertising middleware, the major brands are being outsmarted by the OTAs. In over 60%-70% of cases their ads are not being shown on the pricing menus (HeBS Digital Research). 
 
Hotel price ads are served primarily at the local content and search level, where the hotel property business profile resides (Google+ Local, Google Maps, etc.). According to top Google executives, “the HPA was conceptualized for independent hotels and for property-level marketing efforts;” however, independent hotels have been largely excluded from the Google HPA program until now.
 
The Good News:  Google HPA is Now Available to Any Independent Hotel, Resort, and Casino
 
For the past 18 months, HeBS Digital has worked with Google’s engineers to develop the CPC Gateway, designed to level the playing field between OTAs and hoteliers. The proprietary CPC Gateway connects hoteliers’ inventory and pricing to Google’s system, enabling any hotel or group of hotels to become part of the Google HPA program at an affordable monthly rate. Participation in the Google HPA program brings in much-needed incremental revenue through the direct online channel and shifts bookings from the OTAs to the hotel website.
 
How does it work? Properties set up a monthly ad budget of as low as $250 per month and pay a click fee (CPC) for any direct lead. The bids vary from as low as $.20 to as high as $5 based on the competition in the hotel’s destination.  To date, we have observed an average CPC of $1-$2.
 
Once an advertiser is selected from the drop-down pricing menu, the user is directed to the hotel’s booking engine/CRS to complete the booking. HeBS Digital’s marketing team uses the proprietary CPC Gateway to manage the property’s daily and monthly budget and to optimize the property bids and campaigns in real-time.



Each pricing ad menu contains four spots organized by rate, lowest to highest. As long as two advertisers are offering the same price, bidding can increase their position. However, a lower price would typically be displayed above a higher rate, providing additional incentive for hotels to always operate in strict rate parity with the OTAs. For example, if two advertisers have the same rate of $100/night, their position will be determined by the higher bid. If one advertiser is offering a rate of $90/night and the other is offering $100/night, the advertiser offering $90 will be listed above the other advertiser.
 
Case Study: Is the Google HPA Program a Viable Revenue-Generating Ad Format?  

Our experience over the past 18 months clearly indicates that the Google HPA program is a must-have for any independent hotel, resort or casino as part of the property’s comprehensive multi-channel digital marketing efforts to shift share from the OTAs to the hotel website.
 
In the case study below, we have reviewed the results for a number of 4- and 5-star properties that have been part of the Google HPA program. These hotel clients, located across the country, were among the first to take advantage of this new CPC ad format and increase their presence throughout the Google network. Here is a snapshot of the Google HPA cost, revenue and return-on-ad-spend (ROAS):

Hotel

Cost

Revenue

ROAS

True ROAS*

Miami Hotel

$5,824.20

$33,767.20

579%

773%

4-Star Hotel CA

$2,131.66

$14,009.44

657%

876%

Manhattan Luxury Hotel

$335.94

$12,148.21

3,616%

4,821%

Los Angeles Hotel

$1,025.45

$10,802.90

1,053%

1,405%

New Orleans Hotel

$1,130.69

$8,376.18

740%

987%

Nashville Hotel

$508.75

$6,526.02

1,282%

1,709%

Florida Resort

$386.57

$6,396.32

1,654%

2,205%

Full-Service Hotel PA

$354.14

$5,007.40

1,413%

1,884%

Arizona Resort

$615.80

$4,872.26

791%

1,055%

Atlanta Hotel

$215.73

$1,769.00

820%

1,093%


True ROAS takes into account the savings the property enjoyed by not having to pay commission to the OTAs. Remember, any direct booking for your hotel via the Google HPA program is one less booking from the OTAs.   
 
Across the HeBS Digital hotel portfolio, participating hotels typically generate an average ROAS of 900% to 1200%. In addition, our analysis shows that participation in the Google HPA program generates on average 3 times more conversions than a traditional lead from Google paid search (AdWords). 

Conclusion
Luckily for independent hotels, resorts and casinos, smaller and mid-size hotel brands, there are new digital technology solutions that allow hoteliers to participate in a suite of important revenue-generating programs such as the Google HPA program. In our view, Google’s HPA program is a must-have digital marketing initiative for any property that provides incremental revenue at a very acceptable ROAS. Hoteliers should budget for this new marketing opportunity to generate direct bookings and protect their hotel’s presence on Google from being hijacked by the OTAs. 

Partner with our digital technology and marketing firm to see how you can get started with the Google HPA program. HeBS Digital goes above and beyond to deliver ROI on every dollar and focuses on new initiatives such as Google HPA that generate incremental revenue and shifts market share from the OTAs to the hotel website. 

About the Authors and HeBS Digital
Sue Wiker and Sara O’Brien are managers at HeBS Digital, the hospitality industry’s leading full-service digital technology and marketing firm based in New York City (www.HeBSdigital.com).
 
HeBS Digital has pioneered many of the best practices in hotel digital technology and marketing, and direct online channel best practices and strategies. The firm has won over 250 prestigious industry awards for its digital marketing and website design services, including numerous Adrian Awards, Davey Awards, W3 Awards, WebAwards, Magellan Awards, Summit International Awards, Interactive Media Awards, IAC Awards, etc.
 
A diverse client portfolio of top-tier major hotel brands, luxury and boutique hotel brands, resorts and casinos, hotel management companies, franchisees and independents, and CVBs are benefiting from HeBS Digital’s direct online channel strategy and digital marketing expertise. Contact HeBS Digital’s consultants at (212) 752-8186 or success@hebsdigital.com. 

.

Editorial Contact:

Mariana Mechoso Safer
HeBS Digital
Phone: 212-752-8186
Email: mariana@hebsdigital.com
Web: www.hebsdigital.com
Facebook: www.facebook.com/hebsdigital
Twitter: twitter.com/HeBS_NYC
LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/company/hospitality-ebusiness-strategies



.
Receive Your Hospitality Industry Headlines via Email for Free! Subscribe Here

To Learn More About Your News Being Published on Hotel-Online Inquire Here


Also See: A Call to Arms: How to Shift Market Share from the OTAs to the Hotel Website / Max Starkov / April 2013

HeBS Digital Continues to Raise the Bar with Four Internet Advertising Competition Awards / April 2013

A Blueprint to SEO Success: Creating Professional and Engaging Copy for the Hotel Website / Erica Garza / April 2013

How Can Hoteliers Take Full Advantage of Pinterest? / Erica Garza / May 2012

HeBS Digital to Present at EyeforTravel's Online Marketing Strategies for Travel 2012 / May 2012

HeBS Digital Announces Loews Hotels Website Re-Launch / April 2012

Hotel Website Analytics: Is There Such Thing as Free Lunch? A Comparative Analysis of Adobe SiteCatalyst and Google Analytics / Adam Hammock and Lindsay Denninger / April 2012

Will the Hospitality Industry Tango with Tingo? / Max Starkov / April 2012

HeBS Digital Wins Big with Two 'Best of Industry' Advertising Competition Awards / March 2012

Top Ten Search Engine Marketing Do's and Don'ts in 2012 / Tara Rattigan and Toby Tornay / March 2012

Converging Social & Mobile: Why 2012 is going to be 'The Year of SoLoMo' Part II / Margaret Mastrogiacomo & Ritesh Gupta / March 2012

The New Google Venice Update - Is Your Hotel Website Optimized for Hyper-Local SEO? / Sue Wiker & Eric Rattner / March 2012

Action Plan to Ensure Your Hotel Website is ADA-Compliant / Gabriel Aponte / March 2012

Can TripAdvisor Transform Itself From an Industry Foe to an Industry Friend? / Max Starkov / February 2012

HeBS Digital Launches Landmark Sixth Annual Benchmark Survey on Hotel Digital Marketing Strategies / February 2012

Jason Price of HeBS Digital to Receive 'Top 25' Most Extraordinary Minds in Travel Industry at HSMAI'S Adrian Awards; HeBS Digital Honored a Second Time in Three Years / January 2012

Smart Hotelier's 2012 Top Ten Digital Marketing Resolutions / Max Starkov and Mariana Mechoso Safer / January 2012

Hotelier’s 2011 Top Ten Internet Marketing Resolutions / Max Starkov and Mariana Mechoso Safer / January 2011

The HeBS Perspective: Members-Only, Flash Sales and Group Buying Sites – Are These New Retail Concepts a Good Idea for Hotel Distribution? / Sara O’Brien / December 2010

The HeBS Perspective: Hotel Mobile Apps vs. Hotel Mobile Websites / Max Starkov / December 2010

Focus on ROI Driven Hotel Website Design and Multichannel Marketing Results in Significant Hotel Online Revenues and … Major Awards / November 2010

Hospitality eBusiness Strategies to Speak at EyeforTravel’s Customer Centric Strategies for Travel 2011 in Atlanta / November 2010

Hospitality eBusiness Strategies Continues its Tradition of Excellence in Website Design with Eight W³ Awards / November 2010

Hospitality eBusiness Strategies Wins One Gold and Two Silver Magellan Awards for Web 2.0 and Multichannel Marketing Initiatives / September 2010

Hospitality eBusiness Strategies to Present during Mobile Technology & Travel Keynote Session at EyeforTravel s Travel Distribution Summit / August 2010

Hospitality eBusiness Strategies Wins Best in Class Interactive Media Award for the Silver Legacy Resort Casino Website / July 2010
...

To search Hotel Online data base of News and Trends Go to Hotel.OnlineSearch

Home | Welcome | Hospitality News
| Industry Resources

Please contact Hotel.Online with your comments and suggestions.