By Roger Cline and John Nendick / Andersen
In times of uncertainty, business executives have more than a normal
share of things to keep them awake. Some of the most obvious worries surrounding
today's business environment across all industries and geographies include
the recessionary economy, a vacillating and occasionally swooning stock
market, skittish customers, competitive pricing and worried lenders.
Beyond these, there are others causing sleep deprivation-the collection
of issues that keep our busy industry leaders up at night. We call these
hospitality's "stay awake" issues. And as issues, they need to be
articulated as questions - the kinds of questions that CEOs should ask
themselves and their senior management teams. These issues fall into a
number of broad categories:
-
Human capital
-
Customer relationship management
-
Distribution
-
Brand management
-
Cost control/operating efficiency
-
Metrics
-
Capital
-
Growth and development
-
Procurement
At Andersen, we focus a great deal of attention on these areas by defining
the issues and designing solutions for their resolution. In this first
of two articles, we will present some of the most significant issues within
the first five of the above nine categories. In our next article, we'll
cover the balance.
Human capital
Heading the list of "stay awake" issue categories for most industry
executives is human capital-running the gamut from recruitment, training
and development to motivation, retention and compensation. Hospitality
is a people-intensive business-not only lots of customers to worry about
serving well but also multitudes of employees or, as they frequently say
in the trade these days, associates.
As we found out in our survey on people in the industry, one of the
problems is that hospitality enterprises tend to view human capital management
from an administrative rather than a strategic point of view. While human
capital strategy should be high on everyone's agenda, it is especially
important in an industry like ours that's beset with high levels of turnover,
low levels of motivation, challenges with training and development, and
disadvantages relative to other industries in terms of image, reputation
and pay scales. Gone are the days when a personnel director can fulfill
this need from a mid-level position within the organization. Such a function
must report to the top and be seen as fundamental to the success of the
organization.
High turnover of people is extremely expensive. As with customers,
it is a great deal more productive to invest in the retention of existing
employees than to recruit and develop new ones. Root course analysis deployed
in areas of the company with high levels of turnover needs to identify
factors that are both controllable and intractable, with solutions developed
to mitigate the factors that can be controlled.
The hospitality industry also needs to learn from both its own industry
leaders and from best-practice companies in other sectors. One theory in
hospitality management is that a clear relationship exists between employee
and customer satisfaction, which in turn drives profitability. While it's
a simple theory, it's evidently not adopted by all. Hospitality managers
don't always measure employee satisfaction adequately enough to foster
and manage this virtuous sequence. For some companies, the presence of
a particular culture can also either hinder or help progress. In mergers,
for example, conflicting cultures are frequently the principal causes of
failure of companies to deliver on the promises of organizational synergy.
Managers face a number of questions related to human capital:
-
How can we manage our human capital more strategically?
-
Does our human capital strategy, organization and culture foster development
and retention of our best people?
-
How do we adequately develop our executive talent?
-
How do we ensure that our compensation program is adequate to attract and
retain the best and the brightest?
-
How can we mitigate the high costs of employee turnover?
-
How can we encourage employee loyalty?
-
Do we adequately measure employee satisfaction?
-
Does our culture support or hinder growth? How might we change the culture,
if necessary?
Customer relationship management
If human capital is the number-one worry, not far behind is how to
relate to customers. Placing the customers at the very center of
an organization's universe is a generally accepted business practice these
days-but, at least for most hospitality enterprises it's easier said than
done.
First, hospitality companies must migrate from their traditional focus
on physical assets to one of customer orientation. Customer relationship
management, or CRM, is a popular topic in today's business literature and
reflects the set of values most companies have embraced but, again, with
a lot of variation in how it is interpreted and implemented.
The challenge for management is to provide clarity of vision and then
drive the company's CRM strategy toward this singular vision. Managers
typically have a variety of opinions as to where to place emphasis, especially
if as is frequently the case, resources are limited and capital must be
allocated or phased.
Like so many hospitality IT projects, CRM is frequently launched without
an adequate business case in place, making the process of measuring and
monitoring progress quite challenging. The task at the front end of any
CRM project should be to define guest loyalty enhancements, revenue enhancement
potential and costs savings and then the metrics used to measure performance
of the CRM system.
Designing and developing a complex CRM system requires a broad base
of marketing, organization, technical and financial skills. The existence
of third-party owners of hotel properties (under management or franchise
agreements) presents particular challenges in obtaining buy-in to an enterprise-wide
CRM system, since management may not control the investment decisions and,
in the franchising context the ownership of customer data is an issue.
Management also needs to ensure that CRM drives increased productivity
in sales and marketing by restructuring the process to ensure it leverages
everything a CRM system can deliver. Unfortunately, so-called loyalty programs
don't always house a hospitality company's most loyal or valuable customers.
Behavioral, attitudinal and demographic factors must be triangulated to
truly value the customer asset.
Loyalty programs are generally very expensive and with some exceptions
may not be worth the investment - the ROI on such systems is often ignored
and capital is wasted. Also, hospitality companies very seldom engage
in comprehensive and effective market research. Guest comment cards, for
example, are a very poor and primitive system and yet are used throughout
the industry. More sophisticated methods must be developed to better understand
customer attitudes.
The typical hospitality company has many customer touch-points (the
hotel, the central reservation system's call centers, the website, the
sales office, global distribution systems), some of which the company doesn't
always control or where there is little deployment of technology to capture
customer information.
Thus, the "stay awake" issues for the hospitality industry executive
considering, embarking-on or managing a CRM system appear to be as follows:
-
How should CRM fit into our overall strategy?
-
What are the key elements of a successful CRM system? o Which elements
of CRM are appropriate for our enterprise?
-
What is the business case for CRM?
-
What is the process for design and development of a CRM system?
-
What are the constraints presented by varying ownership, management and
franchise systems throughout our portfolio?
-
How will CRM improve the productivity of our sales and marketing people
and marketing expenditures?
-
How should we measure customer loyalty?
-
Do our loyalty programs improve customer loyalty? What is the ROI on such
programs?
-
How can we improve our market research and integrate the results into a
CRM system?
-
How can we integrate the multiple customer touch-points of our business?
-
Who within the industry deploys best practices in CRM?
-
What are the lessons learned from other industries' experiences?
-
How ready is our organization for the financial investment and cultural
change that moving to a sophisticated CRM system will require?
Distribution
With the advent of online travel distribution solutions, the traditional
agency relationships between hotel suppliers and travel agencies and wholesalers
are changing rapidly. As a result, customer relationships are being disintermediated,
and industry marketing executives need to track and understand the fast-changing
dynamics of this sector.
On the basis of Andersen's global research study on e-Business, Internet-based
room reservations are projected to grow from five to 15 percent of total
bookings over the next two years. And Internet-influenced reservations
(where information is sought on the net but reservations are made to call
centers or hotels) is growing exponentially. But many hospitality websites
can't take reservations, and only a few have a single image of their rooms
inventory (i.e., one that appears the same from all booking points).
With distribution channels in a state of flux, hospitality companies
must continually review each of their relationships and systems of distribution
and look for new opportunities to distribute more of their product to both
wider and more focused audiences at reduced cost.
The priority for most hospitality companies is to reduce the high costs
of distribution which over the years have escalated due to the various
fees paid to intermediaries. Since e-Distribution represents the lowest-cost
solution (at least at the margin), companies need to increase the proportion
of their reservations booked electronically; however, they require a sound
e-Business strategy and implementation plan to get there. Progress in e-Commerce
is often hindered by the lack of a system to measure results -again a plan
is needed to ensure the implementation of such a system.
Following the dot.com bust, a number of companies in the e-Distribution
game are either gone or are struggling to survive. Large suppliers in the
meantime are building online strength with some of them broadening their
reach through the acquisition of additional channels of distribution or
the formation of strategic alliances in key spaces.
Despite the recognized benefits of yield management (promising revenue
increases of five to seven percent), most hospitality enterprises have
not embraced the concept in a structured way and don't have yield management
integrated into other key systems, such as CRM. Some of the distribution
"stay awake" issues appear to be:
-
How are the distribution channels in the travel, tourism and hospitality
sectors changing?
-
Are we in a sound position to benefit from these changes? What are our
vulnerabilities and how do we mitigate them?
-
Do we have the right distribution relationships in place? Where should
we look for new and more productive ones?
-
What should the role of electronic distribution be in our overall sales
and marketing strategy?
-
How is the consolidation in distribution likely to impact our business?
-
How can we reduce the cost of distribution?
-
Have we optimized our opportunities on the Internet? Do we have the right
metrics in place to measure our results?
-
Do we have a clear Internet strategy?
-
How should yield management be integrated into our distribution system?
-
Should we focus on maximizing direct reservations via our own website or
look for strategic alliances (whether inside or outside the industry) to
drive leverage and efficiency in online reservations?
Brand management
Branding has become a critical component of success and enterprise value
in the international hospitality sector. Although there is far greater
use of brands in the U.S. than elsewhere in the world, the use of brands
and the recognition of their critical role is growing rapidly.
Brand loyalty is very shallow in the hospitality industry, and for some
constituencies (especially third-party owners and independent management
companies) the relative values of alternative brands are open to much questioning.
Key responses to this issue are tight market research that monitors customer
loyalty and CRM systems that relate behavior to attitudes.
With hundreds of different branded products and services competing in
various segments of the hospitality sector, the issue of how to optimize
an individual property's performance and a chain's results frequently revolve
around brand positioning and the supporting management infra-structure.
While a hospitality enterprise may have well-developed brands, they
may not be appropriately positioned in the marketplace for a variety of
reasons. For many larger hospitality companies, brand coverage across all
price points and product types is a long-range goal to ensure market coverage
and optimum cross-selling across all market segments.
The challenge for many brand managers is the lack of consistency that
is endemic in the industry as a result of the multiple constituencies involved
in capital spending decisions and high turnover and low sophistication
of those who deliver the brand-the hotel employees. While this is particularly
true in franchising, it is also prevalent in the management contract business.
Since a brand is a promise of consistency, brand managers need to reconcile
these conflicting interests if a branding strategy is ever to succeed.
Brands are also extremely expensive to build in today's environment.
Success has generally come to those companies who have tightly engineered
the product, taken on the financial responsibility for its early development
and have taken these steps in a strong upturn in the real estate development
cycle (hardly the current environment). As a result, critical mass has
been an elusive target for most brand builders.
With the challenges of building brand loyalty and the difficulty of
measuring success, many hospitality companies continue to struggle with
these fundamental issues. Although successful brands add significantly
to enterprise value, they are rarely valued in the normal course of business.
As hospitality industry executives ponder the issues around branding,
here are some questions they need to ask:
-
What is our brand strategy?
-
What are our existing and prospective customers' attitudes to our brands?
-
Is our enterprise adequately supported with optimum brand positioning and
brand management?
-
Are our brands appropriately positioned in the marketplace? o Do
we have the right mix of brands?
-
How do we maintain product and service consistency in support of our brands'
value?
-
Should we build or buy brands in the future?
-
How should we build brand loyalty?
-
How would we measure success?
-
How do we value our brands?
-
How do third-party owners and investors value our brands?
Cost control / operational efficiency
We decided to address the issues surrounding cost control and operational
efficiency last in this article, but not because they fall to the lowest
level of priority. To the contrary, cost control is an area that is front
and center for most companies, especially in the face of a continued economic
recession and particularly in the aftermath of the events of Sept. 11.
Both of these factors have brought into sharp focus the need for companies
and hotel properties to cut costs and reorganize in the face of sharply
reduced and fluctuating business volumes.
With the increasing volatility of the business cycle, the vulnerability
of the sector to declines in economic growth and the current sharp downturn
in trading conditions, hospitality companies need to find new and innovative
ways to trim costs without jeopardizing long-term asset values (both physical
and intangible). While companies frequently revisit their strategies, they
less frequently reevaluate their business model and organizational structure
to ensure that it is well-synchronized with the strategy.
In the three major areas of enterprise activity (customer relationship
management, infrastructure and product development), few companies have
the requisite core competencies in all functions within each of these areas;
thus, we've seen the growing popularity of outsourcing.
The hospitality industry has a variety of alternative business forms,
some of which appear well-suited to the particular circumstances of a company
and its strategies and others much less so. However, companies that short-change
the investments they need to make in their organizational assets do so
at their peril.
In an era in which cost cutting and productivity are in sharp focus,
the issue of how to deliver corporate support and services to the field
is on many corporate agendas. With large corporate infrastructures, many
companies are reassessing how they might reorganize to better serve the
needs of the field. They're also reassessing labor productivity standards
to design models for better scheduling and optimum utilization of human
resources.
Finally, for companies with international growth and development goals,
the traditional models that succeed in the home market frequently need
to be completely reengineered for success internationally.
For our industry's executives up at night, what are the questions they
may ask in this arena?
-
How do we get our costs under control and ensure they are in sync with
the likely changes in our revenue outlook and cycle?
-
Do we have the optimum business model in light of our corporate strategy?
-
What is the best approach to trim costs in a sharp down-cycle?
-
What should be the role of outsourcing in our business?
-
Which business models in the hospitality sector appear to produce the best
results and why?
-
Do we invest adequately in our organization? Where should we allocate our
organizational capital and why?
-
What impact will the current trends in the marketplace (both as to the
way the industry is structured and the way our customers behave) have on
our enter-prise and how should we restructure in response, if at all?
-
How do we need to change our model as we grow internationally, if at all?
-
How should we evaluate the role of the corporate center relative to the
field? Where should we be by function on the centralized / decentralized
spectrum?
-
How do our costs compare to our peers and to successful companies in other
industries?
While we have attempted in this article to surface the most significant
issues that industry executives must contend with these days, this surely
is the easy part. A far tougher challenge is producing the right answers
and executing against a plan. Looking at the hospitality industry "stay
awake" issues in a strategic, objective and current mode, however, should
enable discussions on the appropriate areas of focus and improve the odds
of crafting outcomes that move the meter in terms of business performance.
Roger Cline is a partner with Andersen and the firm's Director of
Hospitality Consulting - North America. He is based in New York. John Nendick
is a partner with Andersen, a member of the firm's Global Hospitality Leadership
Team and coordinator of the firm's Global Affinity Program for the hospitality
industry. He is based in Los Angeles. |